John Mayer is reportedly frustrated with Scheana Shay continuously alluding to a past romantic encounter between them. A source disclosed to the U.S. Sun that the musician has denied any involvement with the reality TV star, despite her not-so-subtle remarks on a recent episode of "Vanderpump Rules." The insider shared, "John has made it clear to his close circle that there was never anything romantic between him and Scheana." The source also claimed that Mayer, 46, actively avoided Shay, 38, at a recent event where they both attended. Shay had allegedly attempted to engage with Mayer and even take a photo with him, but he declined.

It has been suggested that Mayer wants no part in Shay's claims and is irritated by the situation. Shay previously hinted at a past connection with Mayer during a game of "Never Have I Ever," insinuating that they were involved in an orgy. While she did not explicitly name the star, her reference to his hit song "Your Body Is a Wonderland" seemed to suggest him. Shay had previously spoken about her interactions with Mayer during a podcast in 2020, revealing that their relationship progressed into a three-person dynamic involving her and another individual. Despite her past with Mayer, Shay has found happiness with her husband Brock Davies, whom she married in 2021 and shares a daughter with.